Ontology Working Group Meeting, Tuesday June 9th, 2015
Time: 8:15am PDT (GMT-7:00) Pacific Time (US and Canada) Connection details: Join from PC, Mac, iOS or Android: https://zoom.us/j/834566681
- Who will attend: LC, MAL, DWS, PJ, BS
- Others?: , CM, GG
- Regrets: JE, EA
- Link to recording- Video: File: File:Ontology WG 6-9-15 audio only.m4a
- Link to recording- Audio: File: File:Ontology WG 6-9-15 video.mp4
Agenda
Summary from last meeting May 26th ::
- Report form UN meeting- BS- need links to publication
- Updates underway to the Trait Template (Leo)
- Discussion of the id space for Crop Ontologies
- Discussion of the hierarchy of the CO Vocabs- not a problem if the terms have logical def'ns, just import as flat file.
- Mapping to TO with Agreement Maker Light - see below
- Progress on AmiGO2 browser development: http://dev.planteome.org/amigo
- Updates on the transition to Github: https://github.com/Planteome
Other Updates, etc
- Hiring:
- OSU: Offer has been made, waiting for confirmation, undergraduate student hired for summer, another one joining in August
- NYBG:
- Offer has been made, waiting for confirmation, graduate student will be joining to help with the imaging work
- working with the AISO-Bisque team to generate images.
- Idea to do a use case study involving in situ analysis- leaf development or procambium development
Report from Bioversity team
Introduce new Crop_Ontology_Pages on the wiki (MAL)
- Marie-Angelique has created an informative page on the wiki with information about the structure and format of the CO vocabularies.
- Current structure of the Trait template (v.4)
- Future structure of the Trait Template (v.5)
Mappings from CO to TO: MAL
From last meeting:
- Marie-Angelique is testing Mapping to TO using the program Agreement Maker Light (AML) (http://agreementmaker.org/) tool
- Import as OWL or OBO, * Needs to make the product using owl files??
- Add mapping to terms, structure or words
Results of mapping to Wheat Ontology CO:321
- The Wheat Ontology CO:321 has 240 trait terms, with 46 xrefs to the TO (done by Rosemary Shrestha)
- The manually created Xrefs to TO can be used to double check the AML mappings (a caution as they were created some time ago- may be out of date)
- The AML tool found about 73 mapping, case independent
- Results: color coding:
- Green- Xref and AML in agreement
- Orange- Xref and AML NOT in agreement
- No color- new mapping that the AML tool found- about 30 new ones identified, need to be verified.
- Mapping to PO was complicated by the presence of the synonyms, and issue of AML did not want to use the PO terms more than once.
- Examples of lack of agreement:
CO term: CO:321:0000040 grain size Xref: to seed size TO:0000391- AML maps it to: TO:0000397 grain size
Note: Xref Links CO trait definitions which are mapped to Gramene right have been changed to the Planteome page- mainly in the wheat file
Updates on work on Plant Disease Ontology and future plans for Plant Stress Ontology (Laurel)
- Discussion of overall structure and goals: Trait + Stress Dev Ontology
Discussion of Timeline and Plan
Next Meeting Tuesday June 23rd
Back to the Planteome_Ontology_Development_and_Coordination_Working_Group page