Ontology Working Group March 6th 2015 - Revision history

Cooperl: /* Crop Research Ontology Crop Research Ontology */

2015-04-20T23:30:42Z

Crop Research Ontology Crop Research Ontology

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:30, 20 April 2015
Line 65:		Line 65:
	* Barry Smith- Suggestion of ontology building seminar		* Barry Smith- Suggestion of ontology building seminar

	Back to the [[Planteome_Ontology_Development_and_Coordination_Working_Group]] page		===Back to the [[Planteome_Ontology_Development_and_Coordination_Working_Group]] page===

Cooperl at 23:13, 20 April 2015

2015-04-20T23:13:19Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:13, 20 April 2015
Line 1:		Line 1:
	=Agenda Items:=		=Agenda Items:=
	Who: EA, LC, BS, CM, along with new folks: Rosemary Shrestha, Léo Valette, (both from the CGIAR)		Who: EA, LC, BS, CM, along with new folks: Rosemary Shrestha, Léo Valette, (both from the CGIAR)

			* Link to recording- Video: [[File:OntologyWG video 3-6-15.mp4\|thumbnail\|none\|OntologyWG_video_3-6-15.mp4]]
			* Link to recording- Audio: [[File:OntologyWG audio 3-6-15.m4a\|thumbnail\|OntologyWG audio 3-6-15.m4a]]

	==Introductions to the working group:==		==Introductions to the working group:==

Cooperl at 23:11, 20 April 2015

2015-04-20T23:11:33Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:11, 20 April 2015
Line 61:		Line 61:
	Comments:		Comments:
	* Barry Smith- Suggestion of ontology building seminar		* Barry Smith- Suggestion of ontology building seminar

			Back to the [[Planteome_Ontology_Development_and_Coordination_Working_Group]] page

Cooperl: /* Introductions to the working group: */

2015-04-17T18:35:12Z

Introductions to the working group:

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:35, 17 April 2015
Line 5:		Line 5:
	*'''Léo Valette'''- New Crop Ontology curator at the Crop Ontology team in Montpellier, thanks to the allocation of an [https://www.integratedbreeding.net/ 2015 IBP] grant.		*'''Léo Valette'''- New Crop Ontology curator at the Crop Ontology team in Montpellier, thanks to the allocation of an [https://www.integratedbreeding.net/ 2015 IBP] grant.
	- Background: Agronomist, with background in Information Technology		- Background: Agronomist, with background in Information Technology

	- Roles:		- Roles:
	- Collaborate with each crop curator and with Julian Pietragalla (IBP) to maintain quality Trait Dictionaries for the [https://www.integratedbreeding.net/15/breeding-management-system Breeding Management System] and expend the Crop Ontology to new crops.		- Collaborate with each crop curator and with Julian Pietragalla (IBP) to maintain quality Trait Dictionaries for the [https://www.integratedbreeding.net/15/breeding-management-system Breeding Management System] and expend the Crop Ontology to new crops.

Cooperl at 22:08, 31 March 2015

2015-03-31T22:08:15Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:08, 31 March 2015
Line 1:		Line 1:
	=~~Friday March 6th, 2015=~~		=Agenda Items:=
	Agenda Items:
	Who: EA, LC, BS, CM, along with new folks: Rosemary Shrestha, Léo Valette, (both from the CGIAR)		Who: EA, LC, BS, CM, along with new folks: Rosemary Shrestha, Léo Valette, (both from the CGIAR)

Cooperl: Cooperl moved page Ontology Working Group Meetings- March 2015 to Ontology Working Group March 6th 2015

2015-03-31T22:07:18Z

Cooperl moved page Ontology Working Group Meetings- March 2015 to Ontology Working Group March 6th 2015

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:07, 31 March 2015
(No difference)

Cooperl: /* Tuesday March 31st */

2015-03-31T21:58:09Z

Tuesday March 31st

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:58, 31 March 2015
Line 61:		Line 61:
	Comments:		Comments:
	* Barry Smith- Suggestion of ontology building seminar		* Barry Smith- Suggestion of ontology building seminar

	~~=Tuesday March 31st=~~
	~~Attending: LC, BS, EA, PJ, LV~~

	~~Topic: Planteome Ontology Meeting~~

	~~Time: Mar 31, 2015 8:00 AM (GMT-7:00) Pacific Time (US and Canada)~~

	~~Join from PC, Mac, iOS or Android: https://zoom.us/j/106572348~~

	~~==1. Proposal for developing a public-facing Bioportal Instance for the Crop Ontology:==~~

	~~[[File:TestingBioPortal with CO.pdf\|thumbnail\|Proposal for a CO Bioportal]]~~

	~~'''Key Points and Project description:'''~~

	~~Who is involved:~~
	* Clement Jonquet – jonquet@lirmm.fr (University of Montpellier)
	* Pierre Larmande – pierre.larmande@ird.fr (Institute of Research for Developing Countries and IBC project)
	* Elizabeth Arnaud – e.arnaud@cgiar.org (Bioversity-France)
	* Patrick Valduriez – patrick.valduriez@inria.fr (INRIA, ZENITH Team)
	* Pascal Neveu - pascal.neveu@supagro.inra.fr (French National Institute of Agronomy)

	~~From the proposal:~~
	~~'''Customizing an instance of the Bioportal behind the Crop Ontology web site'''~~
	* The NCBO Bioportal is a well-known repository for biomedical ontologies. Its functionalities have been progressively extended, with a new release in February 2015 that aims at improving the user experience when accessing registered ontologies and using it for annotations. An instance of the Bioportal is currently being customized at the University of Montpellier, in the context of the SIFR and IBC projects (in collaboration with Pierre Larmande).

	*This project is essentially a feasibility study for maintaining and supporting a local Bioportal instance for plants, and reusing the recent technologies and services of the NCBO BioPortal, such as hosting, search, mappings, versioning, annotation, REST endpoint, visualization.
	* The main objective is to enable straightforward use of plant related ontologies, freeing researchers to deal with complex knowledge engineering issues and to concentrate on biological challenges and conducting field trips.

	~~===A draft prototype of the BioPortal Plant Group is available at: http://bioportal.lirmm.fr===~~

	* NCBO technology is domain-independent and open source. The NCBO Bioportal virtual appliance is available for the community allowing to set up a local ontology repository and eventually customize it: http://www.bioontology.org/wiki/index.php/Category:NCBO_Virtual_Appliance

	* We have already set-up a local instance of BioPortal on a LIRMM server. It is a prototype that currently hosts French terminologies (for the SIFR project) and English plant related ontologies (around 15) aggregated for the IBC project and testing for INRA. As part of the Wheat Data Interoperability Working Group activities, a group of users will be identified (e.g. IRD, INRA, CIRAD, Bioversity) to use and test the prototype with the Wheat terms and user needs: http://bioportal.lirmm.fr.

	~~As an illustration of what could be done, we have developed an ontology group for Crop-related ontologies, provisionally called the "CROP" group.~~

	~~[[File:Filtered by CROP group.png\|thumbnail]]~~

	~~===Budget for collaboration is available for 1 year===~~
	The Labex NUMEV offers the opportunity to obtain the funding for a 1-year postdoc, starting in May 2015 for joining Clément Jonquet’s lab and testing NCBO technology with the Crop ontology project. The postdoc profile needs to be urgently submitted in order to start in May.


	~~===Possible interaction with Planteome===~~
	This project is a prospective project and must take into consideration the newly NSF-awarded Planteome project. The interactions with Planteome can be assessed along the Bioportal project lifetime. We give hereunder some examples of such collaboration but we propose to hold a videoconference with the Planteome Principal Investigators sometime in March or early April to present our project idea and see if it would be feasible to collaborate in developing technical solutions.
	* In the context of Planteome, the Crop Ontology will align the crop concepts validated by the agricultural community to the plant reference ontologies. We propose to test how the Bioportal technology could support this work?
	* Planteome will enhance the web tool developed by Chris Mungall, Berkeley, called TermGenie, which uses patterns and reasoning to create new terms for an ontology. The Bioportal Plant group project could test the tool and see if it could be integrated into a workflow with the Bioportal local instance.

	* An annotation tool already exists within the Bioportal. Planteome will also develop an annotation pipeline so this Bioportal project could contribute to the test of the Planteome pipeline to identify the best technical solutions.
	* The Wheat Data Interoperability Group has already made suggestions for testing the Bioportal instance and they are also interested by the ontologies of Planteome and using the Crop Ontology concepts.

	~~===Comments and Discussion:===~~
	~~Overall, the consensus was the following:~~
	* The LIRMM Bioportal instance would be useful in expanding access to the ontologies to a wider base of users, especially ontology users who are already using the NCBO version of Bioportal.
	* The CO user base is familiar with the existing site, Trait Template (spreadsheet), and workflow, so those should be maintained.
	* Some tools that would be useful may be the Mapping, Annotator, and the viewer (seems to be missing?), although there are questions as to whether or not they would be effective, as the real work of the ontology revisions and cross referencing needs to be done.
	* In order for it to be useful, we would need to have an instance with only the plant-related ontologies, rather than having to use the sub-group for searches and mapping. The ontologies need to be properly referenced and updated automatically.
	* The Planteome is still in early stages at this point and we have much work to do on both the reference ontologies and the crop-specific application ontologies. We cannot commit to using this portal, but are interested in seeing the development of it and will assess it in about a year to see if we should have a more formal collaboration.

	~~Action: Elizabeth will draft a response and share it with LC, PJ and BS for input. Then we will send it to them~~

	~~== 2. Update of Rice Trait Ontology- Leo==~~
	* Leo has been working on cross-referencing the terms in the CGIAR Rice Trait Ontology (http://www.cropontology.org/ontology/CO_320/Rice) to the reference Plant Trait Ontology, in collaboration with Ruaraidh Sackville Hamilton, Head of the Genetic Resource Unit, IRRI.
	* Of the traits he has looked at, about 95% have a corresponding terming the TO, although he level of granularity varies.
	* The current working version of the CGIAR Rice Trait Ontology is not being posted to the CO website, so it was suggested that it would be a good practice to keep the working copies of the CO ontologies in the Planteome SVN. LC and JE will set up the needed folders and work with Leo, EA and any of the other curators to set up access to it.

	~~==3. Other Updates:==~~
	~~Next meeting- Tuesday April 7th 8am PDT~~

Cooperl: /* Possible interaction with Planteome */

2015-03-31T21:40:57Z

Possible interaction with Planteome

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:40, 31 March 2015
Line 107:		Line 107:
	===Possible interaction with Planteome===		===Possible interaction with Planteome===
	This project is a prospective project and must take into consideration the newly NSF-awarded Planteome project. The interactions with Planteome can be assessed along the Bioportal project lifetime. We give hereunder some examples of such collaboration but we propose to hold a videoconference with the Planteome Principal Investigators sometime in March or early April to present our project idea and see if it would be feasible to collaborate in developing technical solutions.		This project is a prospective project and must take into consideration the newly NSF-awarded Planteome project. The interactions with Planteome can be assessed along the Bioportal project lifetime. We give hereunder some examples of such collaboration but we propose to hold a videoconference with the Planteome Principal Investigators sometime in March or early April to present our project idea and see if it would be feasible to collaborate in developing technical solutions.

	* In the context of Planteome, the Crop Ontology will align the crop concepts validated by the agricultural community to the plant reference ontologies. We propose to test how the Bioportal technology could support this work?		* In the context of Planteome, the Crop Ontology will align the crop concepts validated by the agricultural community to the plant reference ontologies. We propose to test how the Bioportal technology could support this work?


	* Planteome will enhance the web tool developed by Chris Mungall, Berkeley, called TermGenie, which uses patterns and reasoning to create new terms for an ontology. The Bioportal Plant group project could test the tool and see if it could be integrated into a workflow with the Bioportal local instance.		* Planteome will enhance the web tool developed by Chris Mungall, Berkeley, called TermGenie, which uses patterns and reasoning to create new terms for an ontology. The Bioportal Plant group project could test the tool and see if it could be integrated into a workflow with the Bioportal local instance.


	* An annotation tool already exists within the Bioportal. Planteome will also develop an annotation pipeline so this Bioportal project could contribute to the test of the Planteome pipeline to identify the best technical solutions.		* An annotation tool already exists within the Bioportal. Planteome will also develop an annotation pipeline so this Bioportal project could contribute to the test of the Planteome pipeline to identify the best technical solutions.


	* The Wheat Data Interoperability Group has already made suggestions for testing the Bioportal instance and they are also interested by the ontologies of Planteome and using the Crop Ontology concepts.		* The Wheat Data Interoperability Group has already made suggestions for testing the Bioportal instance and they are also interested by the ontologies of Planteome and using the Crop Ontology concepts.

Cooperl: /* 3. Other updates: */

2015-03-31T21:40:35Z

3. Other updates:

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:40, 31 March 2015
Line 134:		Line 134:
	* The current working version of the CGIAR Rice Trait Ontology is not being posted to the CO website, so it was suggested that it would be a good practice to keep the working copies of the CO ontologies in the Planteome SVN. LC and JE will set up the needed folders and work with Leo, EA and any of the other curators to set up access to it.		* The current working version of the CGIAR Rice Trait Ontology is not being posted to the CO website, so it was suggested that it would be a good practice to keep the working copies of the CO ontologies in the Planteome SVN. LC and JE will set up the needed folders and work with Leo, EA and any of the other curators to set up access to it.

	==3. Other ~~updates~~:==		==3. Other Updates:==
			Next meeting- Tuesday April 7th 8am PDT

Cooperl: /* 2. Update of Rice Trait Ontology- Leo */

2015-03-31T21:39:17Z

2. Update of Rice Trait Ontology- Leo

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:39, 31 March 2015
Line 130:		Line 130:

	== 2. Update of Rice Trait Ontology- Leo==		== 2. Update of Rice Trait Ontology- Leo==
	Leo has been working on cross-referencing the terms in the CGIAR Rice Trait ontology to the reference Plant Trait Ontology. Of the traits he has looked at, about 95% have a corresponding terming the TO.		* Leo has been working on cross-referencing the terms in the CGIAR Rice Trait Ontology (http://www.cropontology.org/ontology/CO_320/Rice) to the reference Plant Trait Ontology, in collaboration with Ruaraidh Sackville Hamilton, Head of the Genetic Resource Unit, IRRI.
			* Of the traits he has looked at, about 95% have a corresponding terming the TO, although he level of granularity varies.
			* The current working version of the CGIAR Rice Trait Ontology is not being posted to the CO website, so it was suggested that it would be a good practice to keep the working copies of the CO ontologies in the Planteome SVN. LC and JE will set up the needed folders and work with Leo, EA and any of the other curators to set up access to it.

	==3. Other updates:==		==3. Other updates:==